Preclinical trial comparing radiotherapy alone versus standard radiochemotherapy in three human papilloma virus (HPV) negative and three HPV-positive head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) xenograft tumour models.

Purpose: To perform a preclinical trial comparing the efficacy of fractionated radiotherapy versus
radiochemotherapy with cisplatinum in HPV-positive and negative human head and neck
squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) xenografts.
Material and methods: Three HPV-negative and three HPV-positive HNSCC xenografts in nude
mice were randomized to radiotherapy (RT) alone or to radiochemotherapy (RCT) with weekly
cisplatinum. To evaluate tumour growth time, 20 Gy radiotherapy (± Cisplatin) were administered
in 10 fractions over 2 weeks. Dose-response curves for local tumor control were generated for RT
with 30 fractions over 6 weeks to different dose levels given alone or combined with cisplatinum
(RCT).
Results: One of three investigated HPV-negative and two out of three HPV-positive tumour
models showed a significant increase in local tumour control after RCT compared to RT alone.
Pooled analysis of HPV-positive tumour models showed a statistically significant and substantial
benefit of RCT versus RT alone, with an enhancement ratio of 1.34. Although heterogeneity in
response to both RT and RCT was also observed between the different HPV-positive HNSCC,
these overall were more RT and RCT sensitive than HPV-negative models.
Conclusion: The impact of adding chemotherapy to fractionated radiotherapy on local control was
heterogenous, both in HPV-negative and in HPV-positive tumours, calling for predictive
biomarkers. RCT substantially increased local tumour control in the pooled group of all HPVpositive
tumours whereas this was not found in HPV-negative tumours. Omission of chemotherapy
in HPV-positive HNSCC as part of a treatment de-escalation strategy is not supported by this
preclinical trial.